The kids have rings hanging in their room, and I’ve got some weights in the house. A few pull-ups, a couple of sets, and it puts me in a different position. I don’t want to go reach for my phone again after that. I want to go do something. Sometimes that’s writing. Sometimes it’s the thing I least want to do, like emptying the dishwasher, and I’ll go do that.
In A Stop-Loss for Your Hours, I admitted I’d cut back on the Shorts a little and started playing more phone games instead. That’s basically a wash sale, where you sell the loss and buy back something substantially identical, so on paper you’ve done something and the pattern hasn’t changed at all. If you’re going to cut the scroll, what replaces it has to be a different kind of thing. So once the phone’s down, what goes in the hour?
The hour you protect by not using it
What I’m usually avoiding in those moments is the next thing on my to-do list. Starting my writing, or starting something bigger. I know it’s going to take up some of my time, so I don’t want to commit to it yet.
So I protect the hour by not deciding, and then I lose it to the phone anyway. Scrolling feels free because it doesn’t ask anything of you. The task is still there when you’re done, and now you have less time to do it.
Sometimes those games are just procrastinating on the hard thing. The psychologists Fuschia Sirois and Timothy Pychyl describe procrastination as mostly about mood: putting the task off makes you feel better now and hands the bill to your future self. So the break that’s really avoidance just moves the task to later, and you’ve got less time to do it in when you get there.
Do the opposite
The way out of a wasted hour is the opposite of whatever you’ve been doing. When you’re doing something that’s clearly wasting your time, you find something that’s clearly putting you on the right track. For me that’s often learning something new, lately how to use AI better. Or you do something hard. Train the muscle. Push some heavy weights, or pick something a lot less literal.
It sounds backwards…you’re avoiding one hard thing, so you go do a different hard thing first. But the pull-ups aren’t competing with the task, they get you up out of the chair and out of whatever mood the phone was helping you avoid. After that I want to go do something, and wanting to was most of what was missing.
Which hard thing depends on where you are. If I’ve been sitting a while and I’m restless, I need to get the body moving to get the juices flowing. If I’ve already been out climbing or at the gym, more pull-ups aren’t the answer; sitting down with the thing I’ve been avoiding is. Time, money and energy are all related (The Other Two Currencies is about that), so before you decide what to do with a free hour, it’s worth checking how much energy you’ve actually got and what mood you’re in.
It doesn’t work every time. When it does, a few pull-ups are enough to change which way the next hour goes.
What comes after
The best part shows up later. I’ll come back from climbing or the gym, sit down, and the ideas just come. Some of my best ones arrive in the sauna or the shower, where nothing else is coming in. Usually they’re about work: a way to automate a flow, or a piece of an analysis I want to build, suddenly put together.
The bank reconciliation was one of those. Automating it with an AI assistant took a job that used to take about four hours down to about ten minutes. Then, after a climb or in the sauna, I saw how to take it one step further: download the bank activity on a regular basis and check it against the general ledger as it comes in, rather than all at once at the end. Continuous reconciliation, so there aren’t any surprises waiting at month-end. The next month-end was much smoother.
There’s research on walking and idea generation, too. In a 2014 Stanford study by Marily Oppezzo and Daniel Schwartz, walking helped people come up with more creative ideas, during the walk and shortly after, but it didn’t give the same lift on problems with a single right answer. For me, the idea usually turns up on the climb or in the sauna, and the building happens once I sit back down.
So next time you catch yourself reaching for your phone, get moving: a few pull-ups, a walk, the dishwasher. If you’ve been on the move all day, flip it and sit down with the thing you’ve been putting off. Either way you’ve moved something toward completion, a little bit of a workout or a chore that’s done, before you even find out whether the bigger thing follows.
Taking an hour back from the phone is the small version of this. The reconciliation is the bigger one, hours bought back with AI from work I already knew how to do, and what you do with an hour like that once you’ve got it is a piece I’m working on.
What’s the hour you keep getting back, and what do you want it to be for?
— Ashleigh