A Stop-Loss for Your Hours

Deciding when to leave a scroll, an argument or a job is harder once you're in it.

Deciding when to leave a scroll, an argument or a job is harder once you’re in it.

I did cut back on the YouTube Shorts a little. The phone games, I actually started playing more of. I needed to fill those minutes. If the kids go to a friend’s house, I might reach for it and play a few games because I don’t want to start a bigger task. Or right after they’ve gone to bed, when there’s a little bit of time. Sometimes I come out of it ready for the next thing, and sometimes I feel like I wasted my time. Looking back, the good times were when I either played for less time or I really needed to get something done.

The comparison is a wash sale. Sell a security at a loss and acquire substantially identical securities within 30 days before or after the sale, and the loss deduction is generally disallowed for that sale. Swapping Shorts for games had left the pattern intact.

In those stretches that leave you feeling you’ve wasted your time, that little time adds up, and afterward you don’t feel any better. You might think it’s decompressing, but it isn’t. So why keep picking the phone back up?

Why we hold

In investing, limiting your losses is about as basic as a rule gets. It’s also one of the hardest to follow.

In a 1998 study, Terrance Odean examined 10,000 brokerage accounts from 1987 to 1993. On days with a sale, the aggregate gain-realization rate was 14.8%, compared with 9.8% for losses. Each rate compares realized gains or losses with the total realized and unrealized opportunities of that kind. Investors favored realizing gains. Rebalancing, trading costs and subsequent performance did not explain the pattern.

One possible explanation is that selling makes the loss real. As long as you hold, it’s only on paper.

The comparison is useful for hours too. Putting the phone down can feel like admitting the last twenty minutes were a waste. Walking away from an argument can feel like conceding it went nowhere. And the longer you’ve been in a job, the more leaving feels like writing off the years you’ve already put in. So you stay, and the loss keeps running.

Decide the exit before you’re in it

There are two ways to cut a loss. You can cut the moment: close the app, end the argument, leave the room. That helps tonight. Or you can cut the pattern that keeps producing those moments, which takes more setting up and usually pays for itself, because you do the work once and only check on it now and then.

A stop-loss is the second kind. It’s set for the point where the reason you got in no longer holds, and it’s set in advance, so you make the call before you’re in the moment and able to talk yourself into staying.

Mine for taxes is a reminder. Every year in the fourth quarter, well before the end of the year, it goes off so I look at the tax year while there’s still time to do something about it. I set it because I’ve missed that window before. I’ve sort of learned not to rely on my memory too much, because life only gets more complicated. Your memory’s got enough work to do as it is. (Build Something That Doesn’t Need You made the same case for a business.)

In December, the aggregate loss-realization rate rose to 12.8%, above the gain-realization rate of 10.8%. Odean found tax-motivated selling most evident then. A calendar deadline coincided with a different pattern; the study did not test reminders.

Whole-year realization rates: gains 14.8%, losses 9.8%. December: gains 10.8%, losses 12.8%. Each rate uses its own realized-plus-unrealized denominator on sale days.

Three sizes of the same exit

Twenty minutes. For the scroll, the exit is a condition you set before you pick up the phone: a time, or the thing that’s waiting. If activity reporting is enabled, Screen Time on an iPhone and Digital Wellbeing on supported Android phones can show app use day by day. Look at the available history before you decide whether you have a problem. If you want to put a price on those hours, the Real Hourly Wage Calculator will do it.

An hour. The harder patterns are the ones with people in them. A corrosive hour could be something like arguing, depending on how long you do it. If neither of you is in the mindset to reach a common understanding where you can actually make progress and build on it, it becomes a lot of extra wasted energy that works against you. But if you have the presence to recognize that you see things differently, and you’re capable of seeing the other person’s side and making adjustments, it’s worth staying. I’ve stayed in arguments too long. The condition worth deciding before the next one starts: is progress still possible from where we both are right now?

Years. It scales up, too. You can be in a career too long, or a job too long, where you’re not growing. (The Cost of One More Month is about what that extra time costs.) Investors have a blunt test for a position they’re unsure about: if I didn’t already own this, would I buy it today? For a job, it can start the review. Leave aside whether it was the right call when you took it. Would you take it today, knowing what you know? A no doesn’t settle when you can leave or what needs to be in place first. For something that big, start with a review date. Put it on the calendar, the way my tax reminder works, so the question comes up on an ordinary day and not only after a bad one.

This week

And a harder one. Are your habits serving you? A lot of people absorb a lot of self-help material, including me. Are you acting on it?

  • Write one exit condition for one thing you’re holding. For a time sink, a limit or a condition you set before you start. For an argument that keeps coming back, the question above. For a job or a commitment, a review date on the calendar.
  • Look at your available screen-time history. Name one stretch you’ve been calling decompressing, and write down what would tell you it’s time to cut it.

This isn’t personalized tax or investment advice.

What are you holding that you wouldn’t buy today?

— Ashleigh

New here?

Start with the free check-in.

Five prompts to see where money is buying time, where it is costing time, and which trade you want to stop making by default.

Try the free 5-minute check-in