
We were in Valencia, several days in, having a great time, and we still hadn’t decided where to go next. Barcelona was on the list, so we left it open. That felt like the smart way to travel.
The option was losing value the whole time we held it. Some event had already taken the housing in Barcelona, and by the time we wanted to decide, what was left was gone or expensive. Keeping Barcelona open was the whole hedge, and it cost nothing to hold: no deposit, no premium, no separate purchase. We paid for it later.
The safe option may have been simply another night in Valencia, but adventure was calling, fueling the risk, and somehow the ferry became the safest option. We had the car, we had nothing booked, and everything we needed was already with us.
So we drove onto an overnight ferry, slept on the water, came off it in Mallorca in the morning and crossed the island to a place that would have cost multiples more during the peak season. Then an unusual storm put snow on the peaks and held us there an extra day. When it cleared, we drove onto a ferry that dropped us into Barcelona, which meant we never made the long drive up from Valencia at all.
It ended up working out even better.
It only worked because nobody had to be anywhere. We were travelling before the kids were in school, so we never had to travel during the kids’ season.
We traded the drive up the coast for a night on the water and an island.
Protection that only protects
Most protection is a straight purchase. You pay a premium, and if the bad day comes the policy absorbs part of what it costs you. If it never comes, you paid for nothing happening. That’s what insurance is for and there’s nothing wrong with it. (The Optionality Hedge)
Some protection does a second job. It guards the downside and it hands you something else in the meantime. More stable income on top of the risk reduction. A head that stays clear when the market doesn’t. A deserted off-season island. Once you find a hedge that yields a return itself, you go looking for others. The one I keep coming back to is flexibility: room to change the plan when a better one turns up.
Taking a win off the table
In investing, when a position finally works, the instinct is to let it ride. What I do instead is take some of the win off the table and put it into something that produces income. Real estate is where 17 years of my working life went, in treasury and tax management and private-equity multifamily, so it’s the one I can speak to properly.
That one decision does several jobs. It pulls money out of a volatile position, typically at an inferior risk-reward, which is the protective part. It buys an asset that’s meant to pay every month, and usually does, tenants and roofs permitting. Add a cost segregation study, which accelerates year-one depreciation and may be able to shield some of the stock gains, boosting your after-tax return. Whether you can use those deductions now depends on your circumstances; passive-loss rules can prevent them from offsetting wages or portfolio income. More on the tax side in Zero Is a Legal Number.
The biggest might be the timing. Income arriving on a schedule is a buffer against drawdowns. When the market falls you draw less from the portfolio to live on, or nothing at all, which means you aren’t selling into the decline to buy groceries. It also means there’s cash coming in at exactly the moment the companies you like get genuinely cheap. That’s flexibility at the exact moment everyone else loses theirs.
That’s a financial advantage and a psychological one, and the psychological half is often overlooked. Buying when everyone else is fearful, in Buffett’s phrase, is mostly a matter of not being frightened yourself. The position you’re in will often determine how you react when fear arrives in the market.
Now the other edge. Real estate is illiquid. You often get a steady return, and it spreads your funds across a different asset class than your stocks, but it isn’t without risk, operational and financial. And it takes time. Be careful how you invest there — it can attach greater risk because of the illiquidity, and it can take more of your time, which may end up costing you more than you think you’re making.
Nothing to buy
When I don’t hedge, it’s because the protection is already built into the position.
Two shapes, and I’ll take either. A profitable business with big upside optionality, where the price makes sense on what it already earns, without needing the best case to play out. Or a company trading for less than the cash on its balance sheet, run by a conservative management team with a long record of doing the same sensible things.
Neither is a guarantee, but it beats overpaying and hoping.
Spread that across industries and across valuation profiles so the whole thing doesn’t hinge on one call being right, and you have protection doing its work without a premium being paid to anybody.
Two days a week
In Portugal we paid $8 an hour for someone to look after both kids, 2 days a week. The same help in the Bay Area runs about $34 an hour for two children. I’d been telling people it was a quarter to a third of the US cost. It’s closer to a quarter.
I had moved to Portugal to spend more time with the kids. Leaving the job and the income was the investment in a rare experience: the early years of my kids’ lives, before they entered years of schooling. It bought first steps witnessed first-hand, early connection, and the freedom to explore and travel off-season together. I have the rest of my life to work, to grow, to create. That time was invaluable, and it was affordable.
On paper the childcare is a household expense. What it paid for was 2 days a week when I wasn’t the only adult on duty. Two days of not being on duty meant more left at the end of the day, and more left at the end of the day meant I was actually present for the kids on the days I had them. What you bought was peace.
But not always
Granada is the same strategy with the other result.
We booked it late, on purpose. We didn’t know how long we’d want in Seville, so we stayed loose, and the loose booking cost us. Things got expensive and we ended up outside town, in winter, at elevation, in a flat that was very cold and had some very odd furniture. We never saw the Alhambra. No ferry appeared.
When you’re flexible and adaptable, you can often find a solution when problems arise. But not always. The flat stayed cold.
Being out that way put us near the Sierra Nevada, though. We’d just been through a run of museums in Seville, and the marginal value of one more museum… was lower than a first day on skis. $40 for a lift ticket, $40 for a lesson, rentals for a bit less. By the end of the day my son could ski. That’s a lifelong skill at about a third of what the same day costs in California. We traded one more museum for a mountain.
We didn’t get the mountain in spite of the bad booking. We got it because of it. Same edge that cut us.
Every one of these cut somewhere. The real estate ties up money and time. Leaving the job cost the income. Staying flexible cost us the Alhambra. Flexibility isn’t free. It only pays if you’re willing to change your plans and give something up. So the question to ask of any hedge is what it hands back while you’re paying for it.
Whether you should hedge at all comes down to your temperament and your principles. You gotta evaluate your options and know how it all fits together.
You don’t get the mountain without the cold flat.
What are you paying to keep flexible, and is it paying you back?
— Ashleigh