
About $15K, net of the rebate, to put solar panels on the roof. Buying them was a combination of a hedge and an investment. The savings were easy enough to quantify: roughly $125/month we wouldn’t have to spend on electricity.
That’s $1,500/year against $15K, or 10%, and the tax treatment makes it better. Those are after-tax dollars I no longer have to spend. A taxable investment has to earn more to leave me with the same money. To get the same after-tax return, I would likely need to find something yielding north of 13%-14%, numbers that typically imply significant risk. It gets even more advantageous if you finance the panels, where you aren’t having to pay out of pocket for these essentially income generating assets, using the cost savings to more than offset the loan repayments.
The panels are doing something straightforward: producing electricity we would otherwise buy. The kicker is that as electricity rates rise, that electricity becomes more valuable. The same panels, the same roof, a bigger saving. An investment and an inflation hedge in the same purchase.
The panels also reduced our exposure to electricity getting more expensive. For the power they supply, you’ve paid for the equipment instead of agreeing to whatever the utility charges in the future. You still have a utility bill, and the savings depend on your system, usage, and rates. A fixed-rate loan can hold the borrowing rate steady too, though the interest needs to be counted.
Then we bought an electric car.
The panels were producing more than we needed for the house. Charging the car gave that surplus somewhere to go, and suddenly the equipment on the roof was reducing what we needed to buy at the pump as well. The electricity hedge had become a gasoline hedge.
I don’t think we even accounted for the savings from charging the car off the panels’ surplus.
That is worth looking for when you’re evaluating a purchase: what else does it do once it is already there? The extra job may be worth quite a bit, even if it never appeared in the calculation that got you to buy it.
What the premium buys
Insurance is the classic hedge. You pay a premium so that, if a covered loss happens, you don’t have to bear the whole financial cost yourself. A year without a claim is a good year. It doesn’t mean the policy failed to earn its keep.
The panels do something different. They reduce an expense while protecting against part of a future increase. Insurance can cover a loss far larger than the premium. Those are different jobs, and a return on one doesn’t make the other unnecessary.
Start with the loss you need to cover. Then look at the ways of covering it, what they cost, and what else they might give you. Each case is a snowflake.
Living on the buffer
One of my hedges was keeping a cash buffer. Say 6 months of expenses. When you’re living on a portfolio, that cash gives you room to pay for life without having to sell investments immediately after a fall.
Cash can earn interest. It may earn less than the investments you would otherwise have held, but you don’t know that difference in advance. The cost depends on what those investments actually do.
The practical question is how long you can leave them alone.
When 2 incomes are coming in, there may be money going into the portfolio every month. Without that income, the direction reverses. I described it as dollar-cost averaging out. The groceries still need paying for, and the same spending takes more shares out of the account when prices are lower.
Regular withdrawals don’t solve that. Having cash available can give you time before the next sale. It can’t tell you how long a decline will last.
That is why the cash-flow planning matters so much before leaving a salary. Work out what needs to come out, when it needs to come out, and what will pay for it. A buffer of 6 months has a different job if other income covers 50% of your spending than if every dollar comes from selling investments. Ideally you replenish it when investments have done well, rather than discovering you need cash after they’ve fallen.
Easier said than done. But it gives the cash a job you can evaluate, instead of judging it only against the return it might have earned elsewhere.
Pick one protection and price it
Take something you already hold: a policy, a cash reserve, or a purchase that was supposed to make the future less expensive. Answer 4 questions.
What loss am I protecting against? Be specific. A market decline and having to sell during that decline are different problems. A cash buffer helps with the second.
What does it cost to keep? Include premiums, financing, maintenance, and your time. If the cost is a possible forgone return, write it as a possibility. It isn’t an annual invoice.
What else does it give me? Lower bills, useful skills, income, or room to wait. Nothing beyond the coverage is a legitimate answer.
What would make me change it? A smaller mortgage, a different job, another source of income, or a change in what your family needs. Name the change that would make you look again.
Then make the decision: keep it, change it, or let it go. There is no prize for canceling useful insurance, and a second benefit doesn’t excuse protection that fails at its first job.
Adding the car changes what you count as solar savings. The cash buffer needs a different calculation. Both belong in the same exercise because the point is to understand what you’re getting for what you’re giving up.
Keep the protection you can explain.
What’s one protection you’re paying for now, and would you choose it again for the life you have today?
— Ashleigh