The Budget Club

A job can teach you the work you want to do and still be the reason you aren't doing it.

The budget club kept coming back to a practical question: what do you do when you’re spending more than you earn?

People would get together to talk through spending more than they earned, carrying too much debt, and what it would take to get back to neutral. Then how to pay the debt off. Then, once there was money left over, what to do with it.

I didn’t start the club. But over time, more of the financial questions came my way, and helping work through them was something I thoroughly enjoyed.

The satisfaction came from how personal it was. Helping people with their own finances meant helping them improve how they lived, not just how much they had. Some began to get out of the hole.

The plan behind it

Years earlier, in college, I’d put together a business plan to teach financial literacy to high school and college students. The idea was to help them start well when the first paycheck arrived. Learning to earn money and learning to keep, save, and grow it are different things.

The club brought me back to the financial-literacy work I’d wanted to do in college. It was one of the reasons for starting Breaking Free. That interest in helping people think through their finances kept pulling me back.

But meaningful work doesn’t make the bills disappear. Branching out wasn’t feasible then. There was still a salary to rely on and childcare to cover. The childcare arithmetic was part of the decision, even though helping people with their finances was work I wanted to do.

Knowing what you want to do doesn’t necessarily put you in a position to do more of it.

Laptop and mouse on an outdoor table beside a pumpkin, with a sunset over water in the background.

What a career gives back

What else could this time have done? What else could this energy have done?

The easy answer calls the job a golden handcuff and stops there. Sometimes the handcuff is real. But that answer leaves out what a career can give back.

Mine gave me mentors and skills that still matter: ways of thinking about opportunity, valuation, risk, and finance. That learning helped create the freedom to spend more time on other things. The career wasn’t a waste.

It also made room for some of the work that had been postponed. The club was part of that. A job can help you develop the work you care about while limiting how much of your life you can give to it.

That makes the question harder than whether to stay or leave. Useful experience can justify staying. It can also become an answer you keep giving long after the useful part has stopped growing.

A question to ask at your job

Are you able to invest in yourself at your job?

Ask it about this year, not the whole career. Is the job still teaching you something the work you want to do will need? Or is it keeping you from doing more of that work?

The answer doesn’t have to point toward quitting. The salary may still be paying for childcare and the bills. That can be a good reason to stay. If leaving is something you’re considering, underwrite that side too.

But needing the income doesn’t answer what else you could do with those hours and that energy.

Not wasted isn’t the same as free.

What would have to change for you to spend more time on the work you’ve kept putting off?

— Ashleigh

New here?

Start with the free check-in.

Five prompts to see where money is buying time, where it is costing time, and which trade you want to stop making by default.

Try the free 5-minute check-in